Reality or Official Fiction?
\nDr. Ghulam Nabi Fai
\nWashington
\nIt is perfectly acceptable to be a dreamer. Throughout history, dreamers have inspired societies to imagine a better future\u2014one defined by justice, dignity, and peace.
\nBut what becomes deeply troubling is when those dreams are imposed upon others as reality, even when the lived experiences of people suggest otherwise. A dream, when forced upon a population as truth, becomes a narrative rather than a reality.
\nThis is precisely what appeared to happen on March 12, 2026, when the Lieutenant Governor of Indian-occupied Jammu and Kashmir, Manoj Sinha, addressed the closing ceremony of the 2nd All India Police Kabaddi Cluster 2025\u201326 at MA Stadium in Jammu. In his remarks, he declared that \u201cthe peace we enjoy today in Kashmir\u2014the peace that allows families to gather, athletes to compete and communities to thrive\u2014did not come without a price.\u201d
\nOne wonders what kind of peace he was referring to.
\nIs it a peace where the press is muzzled, dissenting voices suppressed, human rights activists silenced, and political leaders imprisoned? Can such conditions genuinely be described as peace, or are they symptoms of a deeper crisis masked by official rhetoric?
\nOn the very day the Lieutenant Governor was speaking about peace, the Supreme Court of India itself acknowledged the extraordinary delay in the trial of Shabir Ahmed Shah, a prominent Kashmiri political leader often referred to by many as the \u201cNelson Mandela of Kashmir.\u201d
\nThe Court granted him bail, observing that the prolonged delay in his trial could not be justified. Shah has spent nearly 39 years in detention across multiple cases without conviction. If this is the price of peace, one must ask: peace for whom, and at whose cost?
\nThe contradiction becomes even more striking when we consider what happened the very next day. On March 13, 2026, Mirwaiz Umar Farooq, chairman of the Hurriyat Conference and a prominent religious leader, was once again barred from offering congregational prayers at the historic Jamia Masjid in Srinagar.
\nThis was the last Friday of Ramadan\u2014Jumatul Wida\u2014one of the most sacred days for Muslims, when tens of thousands gather for prayer. Yet, for the seventh consecutive year, the Mirwaiz was prevented from addressing the congregation. While official speeches celebrate \u201cpeace,\u201d religious leaders remain restricted from performing even routine spiritual duties.
\nSuch realities raise serious questions about the narrative of normalcy.
\nIndeed, numerous independent observers and international experts have expressed concern over the shrinking space for civil liberties in Kashmir. Professor Mary Lawlor, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights defenders, has repeatedly warned about the deteriorating environment for civil society in the region.
\nShe called for the immediate release of prominent human rights defenders such as Khurram Parvez and urged authorities to end investigations that appear to criminalize legitimate human rights work. Lawlor emphasized that the arrest and detention of individuals for exercising their fundamental rights is arbitrary and demands accountability.
\nKhurram Parvez himself has been internationally recognized for his work; he was named by Time Magazine as one of the world\u2019s 100 most influential people. Yet he remains imprisoned.
\nSimilarly, the arrest of journalist Irfan Mehraj has drawn widespread condemnation. The All India Lawyers\u2019 Association for Justice described his detention as a continuation of the assault on free press and freedom of expression in Kashmir.
\nAmnesty International called the arrest a \u201ctravesty,\u201d warning that the space for dissent in the region continues to shrink. According to Amnesty, the authorities have created a climate where any criticism of government policy is met with intimidation, surveillance, or detention.
\nHuman Rights Watch has echoed similar concerns. Meenakshi Ganguly, the organization\u2019s deputy Asia director, observed that while Indian authorities insist that violence has declined in Jammu and Kashmir, little has been done to restore fundamental freedoms. Kashmiris, she noted, remain unable to freely exercise their rights to expression, association, and peaceful assembly for fear of arrest or prolonged detention.
\nFor many ordinary Kashmiris, the outward signs of calm do not reflect the deeper reality. A young Kashmiri businessman once described the situation poignantly: \u201cIt might seem calm with all the tourists, late-night shopping, and other overt signs of normalcy, but we are festering inside. It is like a soda bottle waiting to burst.\u201d
\nAnother troubling development has been the increasing censorship of academic and intellectual work. In August 2025, several international organizations\u2014including the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH) and the World Organisation Against Torture (OMCT)\u2014condemned the ban on 25 scholarly and journalistic books related to Kashmir. They described the move as a direct attack on freedom of expression and academic inquiry.
\nAccording to these organizations, suppressing academic work under vague national security pretexts undermines democratic accountability and violates international human rights obligations.
\nThe ban not only silences scholars but also threatens historical documentation and critical inquiry, particularly research addressing enforced disappearances, impunity, and human rights violations.
\nThe broader pattern is difficult to ignore. Laws such as the Public Safety Act (PSA) and the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA) have been widely criticized for enabling prolonged detention without trial. Amnesty International and other organizations argue that these laws are increasingly used to silence journalists, civil society activists, and political dissent.
\nEven within Kashmir, concerns are being raised. Former Chief Minister of Jammu and Kashmir Mehbooba Mufti recently urged the administration to stop censoring media and ensure that journalists can work freely without intimidation or restrictions.
\nThese voices\u2014local and international\u2014do not align with the image of peace often presented in official narratives. Peace cannot simply be measured by the absence of visible unrest or the presence of tourists. True peace is measured by the presence of justice, the protection of fundamental freedoms, and the ability of people to express themselves without fear.
\nThe unconditional release of Shabir Ahmed Shah, Mohammad Yasin Malik, Masarat Aalam, Khurram Parvez, Aasia Andrabi, Sofi Fehmeeda, Nahida Nasreen and others will pave the way for creating conducive atmosphere in Kashmir.
\nIf the authorities genuinely believe that peace has been achieved in Kashmir, then there should be nothing to hide. The most constructive step forward would be to allow independent international observers\u2014including United Nations Special Rapporteurs, Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and other credible organizations\u2014to visit the region and assess the situation objectively.
\nLet them determine whether the reality on the ground reflects the peace that is so confidently proclaimed.
\nUntil then, the dream of peace will remain just that\u2014a dream. And dreams, however eloquently articulated, cannot substitute for the lived reality of justice and freedom.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"
Reality or Official Fiction? Dr. Ghulam Nabi Fai Washington It is perfectly acceptable to be a dreamer. Throughout history, dreamers have inspired societies to imagine a better future\u2014one defined by justice, dignity, and peace. But what becomes deeply troubling is when those dreams are imposed upon others as reality, even when the lived experiences of […]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":536711,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[6],"tags":[],"class_list":{"0":"post-536682","1":"post","2":"type-post","3":"status-publish","4":"format-standard","5":"has-post-thumbnail","7":"category-world"},"yoast_head":"\n