Home Editorial Let the Court Decide

Let the Court Decide

0
29

The Islamabad High Court is scheduled to resume hearing the appeals of former prime minister Imran Khan and his wife Bushra Bibi in the £190 million Al-Qadir Trust case on Wednesday, amid another round of controversy over their health and living conditions at Adiala Jail. The couple, sentenced to 14 and seven years respectively by an accountability court in January 2025, have challenged their convictions. With the proceedings already subject to repeated delays, the latest development once again raises concern about a possible line of action turning legal difficulties into political battles.
The Islamabad High Court has already taken steps to facilitate access to legal counsel. Earlier this month, it directed the jail authorities to arrange meetings between the couple and their lawyers to enable preparation of arguments. The court has also ordered the preparation of relevant records and allowed additional time for the defence. These directions should help resolve the procedural difficulties that have repeatedly interrupted the appeals, allowing the parties to turn their attention to the merits.
PTI’s political conduct, however, has often followed a predictable course whenever its founder faces an unfavourable legal development. Court proceedings become occasions for sweeping allegations, disputed procedural matters acquire the dimensions of national crises, and public attention shifts from the substance of the charges to the party’s latest confrontation with state institutions. Such an approach does little to encourage public confidence in the judicial process.
The latest health complaints deserve proper examination. The government and prison authorities have disputed allegations of inadequate medical care and unacceptable prison conditions. The sensible course is to place the relevant medical records before the appropriate judicial forum and allow qualified professionals to determine what treatment is necessary. Every prisoner is entitled to humane conditions and appropriate healthcare. At the same time, medical complaints should be addressed through established procedures so that the appeals can proceed without avoidable interruption.
The Federal Constitutional Court had already urged the Islamabad High Court last month to dispose of the main appeal expeditiously. It called upon both the defence and the National Accountability Bureau to assist the proceedings and avoid needless adjournments. That direction deserves to be followed in letter and spirit. There is also a broader question of institutional respect. PTI cannot reasonably insist that courts provide relief while allowing every adverse development to become grounds for attacking the credibility of the judicial system. Legal remedies come with the responsibility to pursue them through legal arguments. A courtroom is no substitute for a political rally, nor should proceedings involving serious allegations of corruption be reduced to another contest for media attention.
PTI would do well to let its lawyers argue the case and leave the verdict to the judges. The courtroom should be the last place where political point-scoring takes precedence over the administration of justice.