Home Editorial Nine Years Later

Nine Years Later

0
13

Nine years after Myanmar’s military unleashed a campaign of killings, rape and destruction against the Rohingya Muslims, the International Court of Justice has finally called a spade a spade. On Thursday, the world’s highest court ruled by nine votes to six that Myanmar had committed genocide during its 2017 operations in Rakhine State. The judges found that thousands of civilians were killed, women were subjected to widespread sexual violence, and entire villages were destroyed with the intention of eliminating a substantial part of the Rohingya population. For survivors who have spent almost a decade knocking on the doors of international justice, the verdict brings recognition of crimes that Myanmar’s authorities had long sought to explain away.
For the first time, the ICJ has held a state responsible for genocide under the 1948 Genocide Convention. It has ordered Myanmar to facilitate the safe and dignified return of displaced Rohingya, reunite separated families and provide reparations, with the financial details to be settled subsequently. These obligations are binding. Whether they will be honoured is another kettle of fish. Credit belongs to The Gambia, which brought the case in 2019 with the backing of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. A small West African country took up the cudgels for a persecuted community thousands of miles away when years of international condemnation had yielded precious little. Its persistence has shown that even smaller nations can hold their ground when the world’s larger powers prefer to look the other way.
Meanwhile, the Rohingya continue to pay dearly. More than 1.2 million refugees are living in Bangladesh, many in the overcrowded settlements of Cox’s Bazar. Children born in these camps have known little beyond displacement, uncertain education and dependence on humanitarian assistance. Bangladesh has borne the brunt of a crisis it did not create, while international donors have struggled to keep pace with the needs of people deprived of citizenship, livelihoods and security. For families who fled with little more than the clothes on their backs, a favourable judgment offers recognition, though it puts neither food on the table nor a roof over their heads. Nor can repatriation be treated as a matter of putting refugees on buses and sending them across the border. The Rohingya need guarantees of citizenship rights, freedom of movement, protection from persecution and access to their former homes. With armed conflict continuing in Myanmar, particularly in Rakhine State, such assurances remain elusive. Sending families back without them would amount to throwing them to the wolves. Pakistan, which has consistently raised the Rohingya tragedy at international forums, should now work with the OIC, Bangladesh and other concerned governments to press for compliance with the judgment. ASEAN, too, cannot afford to sit on its hands. The UN must maintain humanitarian assistance while supporting efforts to bring those responsible to account. The verdict also carries implications beyond Myanmar. The Genocide Convention cannot be invoked selectively, according to the political standing of the accused or the convenience of powerful governments.