President Donald Trump’s own Board of Peace has delivered a damning assessment of the Gaza ceasefire, accusing Israel and Hamas of failing to honour their commitments and warning that the agreement could collapse altogether. In a 12-page report prepared for the UN Security Council, the body acknowledged the widening gulf between diplomatic promises and conditions on the ground. The findings are particularly telling coming from an institution established by Washington to oversee the very peace arrangement that the American president had championed. Thirteen months after the ceasefire came into effect, Gaza remains a place where the guns have scarcely fallen silent and more than two million Palestinians are preparing to endure another winter amid the ruins.
The writing on the wall makes a mockery of any suggestion that the war has truly ended. More than 1,600 Palestinians have been killed since the October 2025 ceasefire, while Israeli forces continue to occupy roughly two-thirds of the territory. Wednesday brought further reports of Israeli strikes and troop movements beyond the designated Yellow Line. Israel maintains that its operations target Hamas infrastructure. Whatever the stated military objectives, the continued loss of civilian life and destruction of an already devastated enclave raise serious questions about the sincerity of its commitment to peace.
The Board of Peace has now faulted Netanyahu’s government for failing to approve arrangements for a Palestinian police force capable of replacing Hamas. With neither withdrawal nor a functioning alternative administration taking shape, the territory remains trapped between military occupation and political paralysis.
Meanwhile, winter has arrived with its own cruelties. Heavy rains have inundated displacement camps, leaving families struggling to protect themselves in makeshift shelters. The board acknowledges that Israeli restrictions on essential supplies and equipment, compounded by funding shortages, have hampered preparations for flooding. Its $2.45 billion initial recovery programme, unveiled in September, offers a measure of hope. Yet rebuilding schools, hospitals and homes requires access, security and an administration capable of carrying out the work. None can be guaranteed while the existing impasse persists.
Pakistan has particular reason to insist on progress. Islamabad joined the Board of Peace in January and has worked alongside Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Türkiye and other Muslim countries to support a durable ceasefire, Palestinian self-determination and reconstruction. Its participation reflects a longstanding commitment to an independent Palestinian state on the pre-1967 borders, with Al-Quds Al-Sharif as its capital. That objective cannot disappear beneath endless negotiations over temporary administrative arrangements.







