Home Editorial A governance failure

A governance failure

0
250

The recent spell of monsoon rains has left large parts of Punjab, KP, Sindh, and Gilgit-Baltistan submerged in what is less a natural disaster than a governance failure. Over 190 lives have been lost since June.
Punjab alone accounts for more than 120 fatalities. Thousands of homes have been damaged, roads rendered impassable, entire valleys cut off, and municipal services stalled.
In Naran and Babusar, 15 tourists remain unaccounted for. In Khwazakhela, families have watched loved ones swept away. Karachi has once again descended into chaos–live wires, collapsed buildings, and flooded streets. This scale of destruction did not unfold overnight. It has been years in the making.
The Pakistan Meteorological Department recorded rainfall 60 per cent above seasonal norms, but the rainfall was not historically unprecedented. What made it devastating was the brittle state of infrastructure and the administrative fragility that shadows every crisis. Three years after the catastrophic 2022 floods, early warning systems remain sporadic, flood zoning is unenforced, and evacuation plans are theoretical at best.
No one can even dare claim the state did not have time to prepare. The 2024-25 federal budget claimed climate resilience as a priority. But less than 1.8 per cent of public spending is directed toward adaptation. The National Disaster Risk Management Fund lies underutilised. Provinces are quick to invoke Section 144 but slower to reinforce embankments or train district-level disaster units.
In Punjab, the flooding at Kalabagh and Chashma was forecast well in advance, but still, embankments were not secured. In KP, flood drills were conducted only in name. Rescue staff lacked the equipment to operate in remote zones. Sindh remains suspended in the same bureaucratic stasis that paralysed it in 2022. Until the state moves from reaction to readiness, every summer will deliver more funerals, more displacement, and more economic losses.
Pakistan must now redirect infrastructure funding, end floodplain encroachments, and roll out a national evacuation system. The cost of inaction is written across the length and breadth of the motherland. In the graves of the drowned. In the silence of those stranded. In the harvests lost to waterlogged fields. The margins have vanished. There is only now, and whatever the state chooses to do with it.