Home Editorial Blasphemy Debate

Blasphemy Debate

0
208

The Islamabad High Court’s decision to constitute a commission to investigate the recent wave of blasphemy cases has broken a silence that has, for far too long, been both strategic and stifling. It is rare for the judiciary to acknowledge what has been whispered behind closed doors for years: the law serves not only as a moral boundary but, at times, as a weapon.
The sheer number of cases alone did not force this moment. It was the growing pattern of young men lured into online discussions, vague screenshots and WhatsApp forwards produced as evidence and FIRs lodged, not in genuine outrage but through orchestration.
Rights groups have warned for months about a troubling uniformity. The same few names recur as complainants, the same informal networks identify “culprits,” the same fraying legal standard passes off as due process.
To speak too plainly about these laws has never been easy. Social risks are well-documented, and political consequences are even sharper. But this is, by no means, a debate about theology. It is a matter of institutional integrity.
When courts are forced to weigh justice against the threat of public disorder, and police officers file charges they privately dispute, the burden rests no longer on faith, but on the state’s capacity to protect its own.
Blasphemy laws are not being challenged in this commission, nor are they likely to be. The objective, instead, is to understand how the law is being applied and, crucially, misapplied. A precedent already exists.
The Supreme Court, in its landmark judgement in the Asia Bibi case, not only acquitted her but also flagged the contradictions in the testimony.
Going further, it suggested (delicately) that the state must guard against malicious intent. It was one of the few times the law’s limits were acknowledged without sparking institutional panic.
This moment offers a similar path: a chance to recalibrate, rather than dismantle. If the commission is allowed to work with independence, its findings could create room for long-overdue procedural reform.
Such changes would include better screening before FIRs are lodged; protections for judges and lawyers, and penalties for demonstrably false accusations.
The law, in any state, must serve both principle and people. Islamabad High Court has taken the first step. To let it stand alone would be a profound mistake.