Irfan Munir
Hubris can be fatal. In 49 BC, Julius Caesar defied the Roman Senate’s command and crossed the Rubicon River with his army, declaring, “The die is cast!” – an act of open rebellion.
Rome plunged into civil war as Caesar’s forces swept across Italy, forcing Pompey (the Great) and the Senate’s supporters to flee. The aftershocks reshaped history: Caesar emerged victorious, became dictator for life, and his assassination in 44 BC paved the way for the fall of the Republic and the rise of the Roman Empire. Today, Pakistan’s “hybrid system” and political parties are at a similar crossroads amid the heated debate over the creation of new provinces.
Adding to this, Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, Chairman of the Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) – a key ally of the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N)-led federal government and a stakeholder in the existing hybrid political arrangement – has effectively pushed the entire political establishment to a critical crossroads, compelling it to decide which direction to take.
In his hard-hitting speech on November 17, the PPP scion effectively put the entire system in the dock. From the judiciary and Parliament to the bureaucracy and the media, no institution was spared his criticism. In a striking show of candour, he also took responsibility for the “mistakes” made by his party in propping up the federal government that emerged from the controversial February 8, 2024 general elections.
The need for a governance overhaul – or, as Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi has put it, a “system reset” – has been felt ever since Pakistan adopted its first post-independence constitution in 1973, which laid down the framework and direction for the country’s political and administrative order.
After the 18th Constitutional Amendment (2010), a larger share of national revenue was transferred to the provinces, increasing their financial autonomy. However, this reduced the federal government’s share of revenue, creating financial difficulties while major expenditures, such as defence and debt repayments, remained its responsibility.
This created a fiscal imbalance, forcing the federal government to rely more heavily on borrowing to meet its expenditures. Consequently, the federal government urged the provinces to reduce their share of resources and help ease the financial burden. And as expected, the demand was fulfilled to some extent.
However, this has done little to change the situation, as both the common people and the hybrid system continue to reel from economic hardships. Consequently, a proposal was put forward to create smaller provinces or administrative units to improve people’s lives by restructuring the existing administrative and governance system.
The proposal has not been well received by several key stakeholders, particularly the PPP and Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam-Fazl (JUI-F). While the PPP has called for a “political reset”, JUI-F chief Maulana Fazlur Rehman has adopted a cautious and conditional stance. Nevertheless, both have emphasised the need for broad political consensus and public consent before any such major restructuring is undertaken.
Bilawal further clarified his party’s position by advocating for a Parliament-led overhaul rather than a referendum. In opposing the creation of new provinces, Bilawal even warned of bloodshed. He also referred to Imran Khan as a political prisoner, a position his party has consistently maintained since his incarceration, and questioned the Supreme Court’s verdicts that deprived the PTI of its election symbol, the ‘bat’, and its share of reserved seats in Parliament.Follow Politics
Political parties that have sought to sideline the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) have lost their political relevance in Pakistan. Perhaps Bilawal is attempting to salvage the sinking ship of the PPP, but his concerns appear to have surfaced only when he sensed that the hybrid political system might lead to the division of the four existing provinces into smaller administrative units.
His opposition to the creation of new provinces could provide a political opening for the PTI following its unsuccessful long march to secure the release of its founder, Imran Khan.
The PTI’s founder favours the creation of new provinces. Herein lies the opportunity: can the party capitalise on the prevailing political situation and use it as leverage to secure Imran Khan’s release?
Pakistan’s complex political order has always relied on one political force or another to sustain it. At present, the PML-N appears to be bearing the brunt of this responsibility, standing at the forefront of the political fallout. The PTI, however, could find itself in a similar position if it chooses to support the creation of new provinces in Parliament in exchange for some relief.
The political landscape is far more complicated than it may appear. Every political decision carries its own risks, and any miscalculation could trigger a chain of events with far-reaching implications. Pakistan is already grappling with deep political divisions, institutional tensions and an increasingly fragile political order. Another wrong turn could push the country further into a quagmire from which finding a way out may become even more difficult.
The real question is whether political leaders understand the gravity of the moment or are merely pursuing short-term gains at the expense of long-term stability.







