Shamim ShahidFor decades, Pakistan’s policy toward Afghanistan has been driven by a strategic doctrine rooted in fear, rivalry, and a desire for control. From the Cold War era to the present day, Islamabad has consistently pursued this approach to shape and manipulate Kabul’s political landscape, often prioritizing its own geopolitical interests over the broader goal of regional stability.
However, this strategy has brought neither peace to Afghanistan nor long-term security to Pakistan. Instead, it has led to regional instability, international criticism, and domestic blowback. As the geopolitical landscape evolves, Pakistan must transition from a role of manipulation to one grounded in mutual respect and partnership. The proxy paradigm originated during the Cold War, particularly during the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan.
Pakistan’s involvement further deepened in the post-9/11 era, as it publicly allied with the U.S.-led war on terror and secured substantial Western aid, while covertly supporting insurgency in Afghanistan. This decades-long strategy has come at a high cost for Pakistan.
Internationally, Pakistan has faced accusations of duplicity, earning a reputation as a safe haven for militants. These policies have strained its relationships with Western allies, damaged its image at multilateral forums, and hindered foreign investment. Regionally, instability in Afghanistan has spilled over into Pakistan, fueling extremism, militancy, and refugee crises. Internally, the rise of militant groups like the Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) has directly threatened Pakistan’s security and social cohesion.
It is time for Pakistan to reconsider its Afghan policy. A cooperative, partnership-based approach could yield benefits that the proxy strategy never could. Afghanistan and Pakistan share more than just a border; their futures are deeply intertwined through trade, cultural ties, and common challenges. Issues such as terrorism, narcotics trafficking, water scarcity, and regional connectivity require collaborative responses.
Despite long-standing ties, shared religious-ideological alignment, and past collaboration against U.S., NATO, and Afghan forces, the current Taliban-led government in Afghanistan must avoid replicating Pakistan’s long-term strategic depth policy by supporting the Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP). Embracing such a policy would destabilize regional security and undermine Afghanistan’s own sovereignty and credibility.
Just as Afghanistan has suffered from external interference and proxy warfare, it must resist the temptation to adopt similar strategies. A stable Afghanistan requires responsible state behavior, particularly in its approach to neighbors and non-state actors. Supporting armed proxies will only perpetuate cycles of violence and mistrust, further isolating the country at a time when diplomatic reintegration and regional cooperation are essential.
A genuine partnership between Afghanistan and Pakistan would require respect for Afghan sovereignty and non-interference in its internal political processes. It would also involve fostering people-to-people ties through educational exchanges, infrastructure projects, and visa liberalization. Rather than viewing Afghanistan through the lens of India-Pakistan rivalry, Islamabad should approach it as a sovereign neighbor whose stability benefits the entire region.
Furthermore, Pakistan could play a constructive role in promoting inclusive governance in Afghanistan, especially as the IEA struggle to gain broader domestic legitimacy. This could include supporting regional platforms such as the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) or engaging with neighboring countries like Iran and Central Asian republics to build consensus on Afghanistan’s political and economic future.
Of course, this shift will not be easy. Entrenched mindsets within Pakistan’s security establishment may resist changes perceived as concessions.
Trust between Kabul and Islamabad remains fragile, particularly given Afghanistan’s long-standing accusations of Pakistani interference and harboring of militants.
Moreover, regional and global powers will continue to compete for influence, complicating bilateral efforts. Yet, the cost of clinging to outdated strategies is far greater.
By moving from proxy to partnership, Pakistan has the opportunity to redefine its regional role, rebuild international credibility, and contribute to lasting peace in South Asia. True security will not come from dominating Afghanistan, but from walking alongside it as a neighbor and equal partner. In reshaping its approach, Pakistan can turn a history of interference into a future of cooperation. The time to act is now.
The writer is a senior journalist based in Peshawar and an expert on Pak-Afghan relations.










