The fires of May 9 stopped being a political protest the moment they turned into violence, vandalism, and attacks on public and state property. Imran Khan’s arrest triggered a wave of lawlessness that shocked the country and tarnished PTI’s claim of “peaceful dissent.”
What unfolded that day–ransacking military installations, burning public property, endangering lives–cannot be excused. Two years later, the courts continue to deliver verdicts. But the question remains: has justice been served, or is it still clouded by the political storm that birthed these cases?
On Wednesday, Anti-Terrorism Courts in Lahore and Sargodha sentenced several PTI leaders and workers, with some receiving 10 years of rigorous imprisonment. Accountability for violence is essential, and PTI needs to acknowledge its role in letting rhetoric spill into street violence that stained its democratic credentials. Yet, the credibility of the judicial process also demands scrutiny. Justice cannot afford to be seen as selective or opaque.
The prosecutions reveal troubling inconsistencies. In Lahore, the FIR named nearly 400 accused, but only 14 were brought to trial. Defence counsel pointed out missing medical reports and the absence of credible witnesses. Convictions should rest on unassailable evidence; otherwise, they risk resembling political theatre rather than impartial justice.
The use of Anti-Terrorism Courts is equally contentious, as trying political cases under anti-terror laws risks blurring the line between violent unrest and dissent. PTI’s leadership carries responsibility for failing to prevent violence, but extraordinary courts cannot become the default forum for political cases.
Transparency remains the judiciary’s Achilles’ heel. Trials held in camera erode public confidence. If the state truly possessed irrefutable evidence, it needed to present its case openly, allowing the public to witness the rule of law in action.
The accused spent two years behind bars, repeatedly denied bail, with verdicts delivered only after the Supreme Court intervened. Speed without fairness can erode trust as much as delay.
For both PTI and the judiciary, May 9 is a test. PTI must reckon with the consequences of its own missteps, while the judiciary must demonstrate that its verdicts are not only legally sound but visibly fair. Anything less risks turning this reckoning into another chapter of politicised justice.






