Home Article The Double Bill for Fossil Fuels

The Double Bill for Fossil Fuels

0
39

Sadia Noureen and Dr Shahzad Kouser

Every time Pakistan imports a barrel of oil, it pays twice. The first payment leaves the country in dollars. The second is collected quietly in clinics, lost workdays and smog-filled winters. Until both bills appear on the same balance sheet, energy policy will keep treating a single problem as two separate ones.
The opening image captures the double cost — fuel arriving at ports and terminals on one side, the haze over cities and the pressure on hospitals on the other. It is the visual argument of this piece: the country settles two invoices for the same energy.
The first bill is easy to see. Pakistan Bureau of Statistics figures show petroleum-group imports at $16.91 billion in FY2023–24, $15.94 billion in FY2024–25 and $16.86 billion in FY2025–26. A temporary dip changed little. These numbers do not cover every form of energy spending, yet they reveal how much foreign exchange is still committed to imported petroleum and how exposed the economy remains to global prices and the rupee’s swings.
That exposure runs deeper than the import invoice. Data compiled by Our World in Data from the Energy Institute’s Statistical Review of World Energy show that fossil fuels (oil, natural gas and coal) supplied about 90.5 per cent of Pakistan’s primary energy in 2021. Even after a gradual decline, the share remained above 82 per cent in 2025. Primary energy is not the same as the electricity mix; it covers the entire economy, including transport and industry. Renewable power can grow, but without parallel shifts in those sectors the country remains locked into fuel-price shocks that raise freight, production costs and inflation. Households and small firms have little room to absorb or escape them quickly.
Fossil fuels’ share of primary energy, 2020–2025
The second bill is harder to invoice but no less real. Pakistan’s Biennial Transparency Report 2024 put energy-sector greenhouse-gas emissions at 213.28 million tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent in 2021 — 40.9 per cent of the national total. That figure includes transport and industrial fuel use, not only power plants. Greenhouse gases are distinct from the local pollutants (fine particles, nitrogen oxides, sulphur dioxide) that damage the air people actually breathe. Combustion feeds both problems; the remedies are related but not identical.
A World Bank assessment once estimated air-pollution damage in Pakistan at between 2.5 and 6.5 per cent of GDP (2016 figures). It is a historical measure of broader health and welfare costs, not a current annual total caused solely by fossil fuels. Crop-residue burning, waste fires, dust and other sources also matter, and their weight changes by place and season. Honest policy names all of them instead of pinning every smog episode on a single culprit.
What is still missing is a routine way to put both bills on the same page. One practical step would be an annual full-cost energy scorecard for major public projects. Alongside the financial cost, the scorecard would show how much imported fuel the project is expected to avoid, how much useful energy it actually delivers, whether emissions and local pollution fall, how reliable the service is, and who benefits. Results would be published after implementation and checked against the original targets. Independent verification would separate projects that look good on paper from those that deliver measurable gains.
The cheapest gains still lie in using less. Efficient motors, maintained equipment, better insulation and proper cooling cut demand without cutting output. Small firms need finance that is easy to reach and evidence that the savings are real. Transport policy should put reliable, safe and affordable public services first — not merely the purchase of new vehicles — so people have genuine alternatives to private journeys. Rooftop solar helps some households reduce grid purchases, but the remaining grid costs and the needs of those who cannot install their own systems must be shared fairly.
Support works best when it protects essential access and rewards efficiency, rather than subsidising consumption without regard to need. Pakistan will not leave fossil fuels behind overnight. It can, however, shrink its exposure to volatile fuel markets and cut the pollution that is still avoidable.
An energy strategy succeeds when avoidable fuel imports fall, when energy services become more reliable and affordable, and when both emissions and local air pollution decline in ways that outsiders can verify. Capacity announcements alone are not a strategy. The import invoice is only the first bill. The second is already being paid by the economy, the environment and public health.

The writer is a MS student at COMSATS University Islamabad.
The writer is a Professor at COMSATS University Islamabad .