Home Editorial The Indus Water Treaty Crisis — I

The Indus Water Treaty Crisis — I

0
237

Aiming the splash of 21st century oriented warfare commonly discussed as “Non-Traditional Security Dilemma” through which a state can easily target its adversary with “hit and vanish” diplomatically, but such dilemma also has somewhere a conventional realist approach a reason behind its initiating. The abandoning step of “Indus Water Treaty” just after couple of hours of false flag “Pahalgam” fake story shows India’s untutored capabilities behind every move. Indus Water Treaty is a ratified treaty as per “Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties” (VCLT) most applicable chunk of international law, which was knotted between India and Pakistan by the third party of this agreement “The World Bank” as a signatory member, after the long efforts of nine years in the year (1960). Indus Water Treaty is just not limited to the flow of sharing water resources of three rivers each between India and Pakistan finally to the basin of Arabian Sea or may be for India their Indian ocean; it’s a complete concern of environmental science in the region primarily and then globally. What Indian PM Modi was thinking that he will redesign the structure of world both in biosphere and diplomatically? Is this some video game going on? But no wonders what else we can get from a tea-seller PM in his foreign policy. Slaughtering the vision of Nehru the first PM of India, Modi has made India not less than a joke in front of diplomatic umbrella. Cut-off to Indus Water Treaty by any of both states is not a single party choice as per treaty but also keeping it vivid that it is violation of climate control agreements such as Paris Agreement (2015) UN Climate Change Conference (COP-21) and Sustainable Development Goal’s (SDG’s).
Indus Water Treaty is a negotiation in the nature of permanent agreement on which both India and Pakistan are party to regulate their internal waterways for mutual development through these water resources, as prior both states were part of united India commonly called “South Asia” since after 1947 separation, the water resource of six main rivers under “Indus Waters Commission” are not independent property of any single state associated to South Asia as well as both party member states and signatory body. This clearly informs that Indus Water Treaty is a universal pact which cannot be discontinued. The time-frame of nine years process before it formally finalized in 1960 at Karachi, tells us that it’s not state oriented agreement but one of the Post World War-2 agreement designed according to peace settlements globally.
Though internal water remains as subject of state itself, but natural resource are common shared heritage for mankind and environmental life cycle. Here it’s obvious to clarify that Indus Water Treaty is not only limited to debate on water resources through common rivers but it’s far beyond then just an ordinary treaty, what makes World Bank as signatory member and why Indus Water Treaty is quoted in (VCLT). Indus Water Treaty of 1960 has impact on 3.7 billion people on earth today. Let’s be factual and not just see it from the Pakistan-India point of view but through global visionary eye. A Zip-line of water flow from Himachal Pradesh to Punjab of both side continuing into Haryana and Sind finally felling into Arabian Sea can be a limited proclamation to relate Indus Water Treaty, but if it is seen through the map of resource management globally we are taking about 34 Parallel north to Zero equatorial line. So if India intends to terminate Indus Water Treaty in 2025 they are actually bringing disturbance to at least 20+ states.
The false flag of Pehalgam attack was just a misanalysed trick behind disrupting the Indus Water Treaty, water scarcity is one of the major threat to environment of this century, which can lead to end of human existence, threat to life-stock and agricultural reserves as well as climatic misbalances. India tried its controversial security approach through self-planted Pahalgam attack just to ignite the reason for hanging the balance through Indus Water Treaty. The combo of non-traditional security means through conventional podium turned into a big misadventure for India in the result of operation “Bunyan Al Marsoos” led by Pakistan against Indian illogical aggression. BJP led government knows that they are incompetent in front of Pakistan defensive preparedness, so it tried nontraditional tool by suspending the Indus Water Treaty which exposed the cracks in regional order.
BJP led government habitual of creating fuss situation in the region did not even understood the mechanism and feature of Indus Water Treaty according to Article 42 and 57 of “Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties” (VCLT) and immediately announced the suspension of Indus Water Treaty, this shows even Modi himself doesn’t know what actually Indus Water Treaty is in its implicational subject as treaty. Under Article 60 of (VCLT) India has no authority to take unilateral stance over disrupting the Indus Water Treaty neither any other party member can do so. The propagandas behind termination of Indus Water Treaty are also against “the law for sea and environmental outcomes”. Even a poor shot in the context of nontraditional security variant as been debated, because backing off from Indus Water Treaty is also not in favor of India itself. The 75 years old PM Modi needs to be replaced from this position otherwise no logical governance will be seen by India as contribution to diplomatic cause.
International Law clearly prohibits states from creating distortion to the natural and ecological means such as rivers, for the purpose of military objectives. Recognized through fundamental annexation in “The Berlin Rules on Water Resources 2004”, which codifies customary law on water resources, and is framed as a war crime under the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court and the Additional Protocal I of 1977.
The non-traditional attack from India over Pakistan by bringing Indus Water Treaty as an agenda will encourage the Pakistan’s justification to attack inside India and demolish its assets related to objectivity of mishandling the facts of negotiation agreement of Indus Water Treaty. India is digging her burial itself by violating Indus Water Treaty, as there is no supportive instrument in any of precedent of customary law highlighting might is right formula, which can defend India’s position in sabotaging Indus Water Treaty. It’s not easy as fake reporting done by India frequently at multiple stages but it is about understanding the norms of diplomatic responsibilities as member state of UNSC. It is about sense of understanding the purpose of international law and why states are abiding it as process to meet mutual means of regional governance in global string.