Monitoring Desk
Repeated headers during a footballer’s professional career may be linked to long-term brain damage, according to tentative evidence from UK scientists.
The research, the first of its kind, follows anecdotal reports that players who head balls may be more prone to developing dementia later in life.
The Football Association says it will look at this area more closely.
Experts said recreational players were unlikely to incur problems.
The daughter of former England and West Brom striker Jeff Astle, who died aged 59 suffering from early onset dementia, said it was “obvious that it [his dementia] was linked to his footballing career”.
Dawn Astle said he went from being “fit as a fiddle to just a shell”, adding: “He was surrounded by England caps, FA Cup winners’ medals, everything he’d won in football – he remembered none of it.”
Researchers from University College London and Cardiff University examined the brains of five people who had been professional footballers and one who had been a committed amateur throughout his life.
They had played football for an average of 26 years and all six went on to develop dementia in their 60s.
While performing post mortem examinations, scientists found signs of brain injury – called chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) in four cases.
CTE has been linked to memory loss, depression and dementia and has been seen in other contact sports.
Prof Huw Morris, of University College London, told the BBC: “When we examined their brains at autopsy we saw the sorts of changes that are seen in ex-boxers, the changes that are often associated with repeated brain injury which are known as CTE.
“So really for the first time in a series of players we have shown that there is evidence that head injury has occurred earlier in their life which presumably has some impact on them developing dementia.”
In the study, published in the journal Acta Neuropathologica, the report’s authors make it clear they were not analysing the risks of heading by children.
The inquest of ex-England player Jeff Astle, who died in 2002, found that repeatedly heading heavy leather footballs had contributed to trauma to his brain.
His daughter Dawn told BBC Radio 5 Live: “At the Coroner’s inquest, football tried to sweep his death under a carpet. They didn’t want to know, they didn’t want to think that football could be a killer and sadly, it is. It can be.”
She said her father was 55 and physically very fit when he went to the doctor, who diagnosed him with the early onset of dementia.
“He went through the stages that people do who suffer with it: he was extremely restless, he went through a stage when he wouldn’t leave the house, he would try to get out of a moving car, he would eat things that you shouldn’t do, drink things that you shouldn’t do – that would make you violently ill.
“He also went through the stage of being socially unacceptable. It was like looking after a toddler.
“The saddest time was the latter stage when we knew the disease had really got a hold of him.
“He didn’t even know he’d ever been a footballer. Everything football ever gave him, football had taken away.
“And he didn’t recognise me or my sisters, he was just a shell. My dad was the most unique character, he was laughing and joking all day long – it was just desperately sad, desperately brutal.
“I wasn’t ready to lose him.”
Mr Astle’s widow, Laraine, from Netherseal in Derbyshire, said: “We’ve been saying this for 15 years [since Jeff died]. His inquest said he died of industrial disease.
“It is disgraceful nothing concrete has been done since by the FA or the PFA.
“It’s all about informed choice. On the back of a cigarette packet, smokers can read about risks to their health.”
The family set up the Jeff Astle Foundation to campaign for further research and is calling for more donors to donate their brains.
But the science is far from clear-cut.
Each brain also showed signs of Alzheimer’s disease and some had blood vessel changes that can also lead to dementia.
Researchers speculate that it was a combination of factors that contributed to dementia in these players.
But they acknowledge their research cannot definitively prove a link between football and dementia and are calling for larger studies to look at footballers’ long-term brain health.
Dr David Reynolds, at the charity Alzheimer’s Research UK, said: “The causes of dementia are complex and it is likely that the condition is caused by a combination of age, lifestyle and genetic factors.
“Further research is needed to shed light on how lifestyle factors such as playing sport may alter dementia risk, and how this sits in the context of the well-established benefits of being physically active.”
He added that for people who are recreational footballers, football injuries are unlikely to cause long-term problems and he pointed to expert advice that the benefit of exercise is likely to outweigh the risks.
A number of previous cases involving boxers and American footballers have suggested that repetitive blows can cause long-lasting and progressive brain damage.
But until now there have only been a few case reports of individual footballers with CTE in the UK and the extent of the issue is still unknown.
The Football Association welcomed the study and said research was particularly needed to find out whether degenerative brain disease is more common in ex-footballers.
Dr Charlotte Cowie, of the FA, added: “The FA is determined to support this research and is also committed to ensuring that any research process is independent, robust and thorough, so that when the results emerge, everyone in the game can be confident in its findings.”
