Home Article Pakistan’s Institutional Response to Disappearance Allegations

Pakistan’s Institutional Response to Disappearance Allegations

0
32

M Arham Malik

Pakistan’s longstanding debate over enforced disappearances has entered a new phase with recent amendments to its anti-terrorism legislation. The challenge confronting the state is twofold: combating increasingly organised terrorist networks while ensuring that every individual apprehended remains within a transparent and legally accountable process. The question is no longer simply how to arrest suspected terrorists, but how to investigate, prosecute and bring them to justice without compromising constitutional rights and the rule of law.
For decades, Pakistan’s conventional criminal justice system has struggled to deal effectively with sophisticated terrorist organisations such as the TTP and the BLA. Threats to witnesses, intimidation of judges and prosecutors, difficulties in collecting admissible electronic evidence and weaknesses in conventional investigative procedures have undermined successful prosecutions. Figures cited in the rationale for recent reforms indicate that Pakistan’s terrorism conviction rate remained around 8% between 2001 and 2020. This prosecution gap has created serious institutional challenges, particularly when apprehension is not followed by a clearly documented judicial process. It has also provided grounds for allegations of unlawful detention and enforced disappearances, making a legally traceable system of custody and investigation increasingly necessary.
The insertion of Section 11-EEEE into the Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997 seeks to address this gap by introducing preventive detention for inquiry for up to 90 days. The provision allows relevant authorities and joint investigation teams to investigate terrorism suspects and collect evidence within a prescribed period before deciding whether prosecution is warranted. The Anti-Terrorism (Balochistan Amendment) Act, 2025 incorporated this provision into Balochistan’s legal framework, while the Anti-Terrorism (Punjab Amendment) Act, 2026 introduced Section 11-EEEE alongside Section 21-AAA, establishing additional security arrangements, including Faceless Courts for terrorism-related proceedings.
The significance of these reforms becomes clearer when one considers the threats confronting Pakistan’s judicial system. Terrorist organisations increasingly target not only security personnel but also judges, prosecutors and witnesses to obstruct criminal proceedings. Justice Muhammad Noor Meskanzai, former Chief Justice of the Balochistan High Court and Federal Shariat Court, was assassinated in Kharan in October 2022. In July 2026, District and Sessions Judge Abdul Hakeem Kakar was killed in Mastung, while Additional Sessions Judge Tariq Lashari was injured. Reports of judicial personnel being kidnapped and law-enforcement officials being targeted further demonstrate the risks involved in prosecuting terrorism-related cases.
This is where Faceless Courts assume importance. Under the framework introduced through Punjab’s amendment, the Chief Justice of the Lahore High Court nominates five Anti-Terrorism Court judges and five prosecutors for relevant proceedings. Their identities, along with those of protected witnesses, remain confidential. Protective arrangements include concealed identifying information, secure documentation, protected signatures, confidential proceedings and voice masking. The objective is to prevent terrorist organisations from intimidating or physically targeting those responsible for delivering justice. However, confidentiality must never undermine the accused person’s right to legal representation, access to evidence and a fair trial. Security and judicial accountability must operate together.
Pakistan’s approach also has international precedents. Colombia introduced its jueces sin rostro, or faceless judges, during the 1990s to protect judicial personnel and witnesses from organised criminal networks. Italy established witness-protection mechanisms through its 1991 legislation, while the United Kingdom’s Coroners and Justice Act 2009 permits Witness Anonymity Orders in appropriate cases. France, Spain, the Netherlands and Chile have similarly introduced legal safeguards to protect witnesses and other participants in proceedings involving organised crime and terrorism. These experiences demonstrate that protecting judicial participants can be an important component of an effective criminal justice system.
Reported figures from Balochistan indicate that out of 90 individuals detained under the new mechanism, five were released where allegations could not be established, while 40 were referred for trial through Faceless Courts. These developments suggest movement from preventive inquiry towards formal prosecution. More importantly, they highlight a fundamental principle: detention is not conviction, suspicion is not proof, and guilt must ultimately be established before a court.
Nevertheless, legislation alone cannot resolve the controversy surrounding enforced disappearances. The 90-day detention mechanism must operate with strict safeguards, including family notification, access to detainees, timely judicial production, proper custody records and independent judicial scrutiny. Every detention must be traceable, and every allegation of unlawful custody must be investigated impartially. Equally, counterterrorism provisions must never become instruments against peaceful political activity or constitutionally protected dissent.
Pakistan’s fight against terrorism cannot succeed through security operations alone. It requires institutions capable of investigating terrorist networks, protecting those who administer justice, and ensuring that every prosecution meets the standards of law. The recent amendments represent an attempt to bridge the gap between apprehension and prosecution, but their credibility will depend on transparent implementation and respect for fundamental rights. Ultimately, the strength of a state lies not merely in its ability to apprehend those who threaten its security, but in its capacity to bring them to justice without sacrificing the very principles it seeks to defend.

The writer is a freelance columnist.